Friday, September 21, 2007

The Elephant in the Room-Certification

Dear Colleagues,

A fellow candidate for office has noted the appearance of “the elephant in the room”, notably certification, on our election list. As a Candidate for President-Elect my ideas are undoubtedly of interest to some of you so let’s have a conversation on this subject.

In truth I don’t believe that certification itself is the major issue. I believe there are two more fundamental matters that are at the basis of our organization’s dissension, a development which has alienated many of our members and must be addressed and solved. First is the exclusionary link between certification and TA status and second is the conflict between central regulation of many of our activities versus greater local autonomy. Quite frankly, I don’t believe that we can effectively address our myriad other needs such as outreach, practice development etc. until we get this briar patch out of the way. I want to bring us out of our stasis and I also want to recapture the attention and energies of our alienated, disenfranchised members.

My position on this is quite clear and it has been consistent for a number of years. I have also frequently posted my positions on these lists We simply need to find more and flexible pathways to TA status and we also need to move towards greater degrees of local autonomy within our institutes as opposed to the imposition of rules and regulations by a national body.

These issues are affecting us deeply, not only by producing organizational dissent but also by contributing in a major way to the turning off of many members to our national organization. I also agree with the supposition that these limitations on local autonomy are directly contributing to difficulties in candidate recruitment with resultant decline in organization morale as well as, ultimately, erosion in our membership and our financial base.

One possible solution which I strongly support is to vest control over the role of certification on TA decisions within our institutes. We can accomplish this with local option. While not a panacea, it would in my view significantly lessen tensions to the point where all of us could work together far more effectively. With local option in place some institutes would have an immediate increase in the number of new TAs and candidates.

Some cautions have recently been raised about this approach but I don’t see the substance behind the cautions. I’m not aware that it would in any way jeopardize our IPA standing. The Regional Agreement has become outdated since the IPA long ago agreed to accept non APsaA training programs.

Additionally IPA criteria for TAs are quite flexible and IPA has no such thing as certification let alone an exclusionary link to TA status. Indeed I believe local option could make our functioning more similar to that of IPA. While it t is true that decision making would move into local institutes it is also true that many are already yearning for this opportunity rather than fearing it.

It is also worth remembering that a robust 57% of our members supported this approach two years ago. I would however agree that we shouldn’t push for putting this before our membership unless we are reasonably well assured that it could pass with a 2/3 vote. I will strongly support this approach if I am elected.

While I have your attention I’d like to let you know about two additions to my webpage (www.wrprocci.org or http://warrenprocci.blogspot.com). The first, for these of you who might have some interest in my personal history, is a biographical statement. The second is an explicit statement of just what exactly will be my areas of priority if elected. Prominent among them are the two issues mentioned above. I will, of course, discuss these priorities in greater detail over the next several weeks. As always please feel free to contact me directly (wrprocci@sbcglobal.net or 626-793-7957)

Warren R. Procci, Candidate for President-Elect of APsaA

Sunday, September 16, 2007

Dear Fellow Members of APsaA,

The American Psychoanalytic Association is a remarkable institution, with a rich, complex history and a powerful presence in contemporary psychoanalysis. It also has the potential for a very positive and creative future. Yet many of you are put-off or even fed-up with our organization's divisiveness, politics as usual, incessant navel-gazing, and at times its unwitting elitism. We are, indeed, a pre-eminent organization, but we are in real need of both the strong leadership and thoughtful humility, that will continue to make our pre-eminence deserved.

We need leaders not just familiar with our organizational and governance structures, or even just dedicated to our unique and important educational agendas, but leaders who are and can be attentive to the diverse needs of our membership, who have the vision for a productively democratic future, and who are not caught up in grinding the same old axes that have hindered our growth and creativity for too long.

Many of our leaders, and those who aspire to leadership, are thoughtful, skilled, and very well-intentioned folks, some with long resumes and stellar credentials. But while governance experience and educational dedication are essential, they are not sufficient to the tasks ahead. Our future leaders also need to be able to generate ideas and proposals with the best interests of all our membership in mind, and similarly must have the capacity to listen, evolve, and create so that not only will our membership feel enfranchised in its own organization but so that our connections with the outside world becomes increasingly generous and robust. This has not happened with the sufficient speed or sensitivity that our fine organization deserves.

I am very earnest in telling you that my candidacy offers us all a chance to build on what we all know is great and generative about our organization. At the same time my candidacy is not subordinate to the old energy-depleting battles, the old unreasoned hierarchies, or the ways in which politics as usual has so often handcuffed our organization and its members.

Mine is not a radical campaign or agenda, nor certainly not a reactionary one. You'll have to look elsewhere for that. My long history of governance experience within our organization and my lifetime of dedication to educational values, gives me all the necessary bona fides for assuming a presidential role. But it is in my capacity to move towards the future with reasonable ideas, with attendance to the important concerns of all our members, and with a real interest in a dynamic future for our organization, that makes my candidacy so important at this stage in our history.

Please take a moment to click onto any of the links above. There you will find more specifics about my qualifications, interests, ideas, as well as opportunities to let me know about your interests and concerns. I will read and respond to every communication, as I am proposing that we all join in partnership for the best future of our organization.

Warm regards, Warren Procci (candidate for Presidency of the American Psychoanalytic Association)

Friday, September 14, 2007

ApsaA Press Coverage

Colleagues,

Thanks to both Leon Hoffman and Kerry Sulkowicz for telling us about their experiences with journalists and with the press. As with so many of the tasks we face in dealing with the contemporary world we are in an unfamiliar environment which requires special skill, persistence, a long view, and a willingness, even an eagerness, to push beyond our usual roles.

It is most likely unrealistic to expect unequivocally positive coverage for any story about us in today’s media but I don’t take the view that we should consider just any coverage as acceptable or good. Without a doubt negative coverage can cause us very serious harm. Our Association showed prescience many years ago when we put both funds and people into our public information efforts. The addition of a staff member dedicated to handling this effort has paid off handsomely and we can thank Dottie Jeffries for many a piece of good media attention over the years. We were similarly wise when we formed a Public Information Committee years ago and staffed it both with media savvy members (such as Leon and Kerry) as well as a number of non member experts.

While not typical psychoanalytic activities these are exactly the kinds of very non traditional efforts we need to support, both financially and with our personal capital, if we are to “stay on the radar” of public awareness. We also need, as both Leon and Kerry suggest, to continue to work at this to become ever more effective. While it is unlikely that this work would be seen today by many members as controversial we should recall that at one time it was. There may be an interesting lesson here. It is unlikely that our Association can advance and thrive if we choose only to “play it safe”.

Warren R. Procci, Candidate for President-Elect of APsaA

Sunday, September 9, 2007

Openness in Campaigns

Dear Colleagues,

Openness in campaigns is a sine qua non if we are to have effective leadership. Miriam Tasini has asked about the relevance of current experience as a participant in an Institute teaching program as a qualification for APsaA leadership. My response, similar to that of most others who have posted, is that any APsaA member possessing the necessary interest, drive, dedication, ideas, etc. is eligible to run and our members will then make their decision. I had thought this issue was resolved when our members endorsed the bylaw amendment several years ago delinking certification from eligibility to hold office, a proposal I strongly endorsed at the time.

This brings me to two points I’d like to make today. The first is the relevance of a candidate’s voting record. In my view this is very relevant, perhaps the best predictor of how a candidate might eventually lead. In this interest of openness here is how I voted on a number of recent matters of significance. I actively supported: the proposal to remove references to certification from our bylaws, the oversight proposal, and the Local Option proposal. I did not support the Renew proposal

Point two, an absolutely central issue of my campaign has to do with just whose organization is APsaA? Who makes the key decisions that affect us? I’d frame it as central regulation vs. individual/local autonomy, or how much do our members want the central organization to govern them locally. I believe this question underlies the issue which is the major source of our current divisiveness, the certification/TA link. I am proud of my long, quite consistent history of standing foursquare on the side of increased local autonomy on just such matters, and if elected this is the direction in which I will lead.

Please feel free to contact me either at this email address or by phone (626-793-7957). Please visit my website, “a work in progress”.
www.wrprocci.org or http://warrenprocci.blogspot.com

With best wishes,
Warren R. Procci, Candidate for President-Elect